Dr. Michelle Andrews, MD
Orthopedic Surgery ·
Female ·
Age 61
Save
Dr. Michelle Andrews, MD is an orthopedic surgery specialist in Cincinnati, OH and has been practicing for 27 years. She graduated from Hahnemann University in 1985 and specializes in orthopedic surgery, sports medicine, and more.
Mercy Health-Cincinnati Sports Medicine and Orthopaedic Center
4101 Edwards Rd
Cincinnati, OH 45209
Insurance Accepted
- Aetna
- Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield
- Assurant Health
- Blue Cross Blue Shield
- Centene
- Cigna
- First Health (Coventry Health Care)
- Humana
- Medical Mutual of Ohio
- + 5 More
*Please verify this information when scheduling an appointment.
Dr. Andrews' Reviews
Likelihood to recommend Dr. Andrews
Leave a review
How likely are you to recommendDr. Andrews?
Average Wait Time
- 10 – 15 minutes
Dr. Andrews' Performance
Office & Staff Performance
What People Say About Dr. Michelle Andrews, MD
Dr. Michelle Andrews, MD
Reply
She used to take time with her patients but since affiliating herself with Mercy Health Systems, the worst in the business in my opinion, she rushes through the appointment and out of the room. I saw her 25 years ago for scoping of both knees. 25 years later, I saw her for knee replacement surgery. She was aweful!
Was this helpful?
4
3
43Ralph in Cincinnati – Apr 12, 2018
Dr. Michelle Andrews, MD
Reply
Flag Comment
I have been a patient of Dr. Andrews for 4+yrs. She has treated me for severe arthritis in both knees, & a meniscus repair surgery on my left knee. I am in need of a TKR next year on my left knee, & will use Dr. Andrews with no hesitation. As others have mentioned, she is a very caring doctor, & spends the time to explain all the options/outcomes with you. In addition, she worked w/ me to delay my TKR for a few years (vs. diving in immediately) to avoid a 2nd revision. Highly recommend.
Was this helpful?2
2Jennifer in Maineville – Nov 15, 2017
Dr. Michelle Andrews, MD
Reply
Flag Comment
I have been a patient of Dr. Andrews for over 3 years. She was with me throughout knee injections in both knees and then total knee replacements in both knees. She is not only very professional, but also an extremely caring doctor. She is very knowledgeable and explains things so you understand what is going on, etc. I would definitely recommend her to anyone who is in need of knee replacements - or any of her other specialties.
Was this helpful?2
2Joyce G. in Fairfield, OH – Oct 20, 2017
Dr. Michelle Andrews, MD
Reply
Flag Comment
While seeing DR.Andrews through my working career she treated me for my shoulder after retirement was doing good with injections of cortisone then I had an auto accident it caused me to have surgey she took great care of me and her staff are as great as DR.Andrews is.I would recommend her to anyone who wants the best of the best.
Was this helpful?2
2Dottie J. Whitaker in Cincinnati, OH – Sep 27, 2017
Dr. Michelle Andrews, MD
Reply
Flag Comment
Dr. Andrews is a wonderful person and an eminent doctor. She has first operated on my mom's knee, and gave her back the mobility and confidence to travel internationally and even consider a Nepal hiking trip. She recently operated on my father's shoulder, the first surgery of his life. Dr. Andrew's outstanding bed side manners put him at ease and convinced him to undergo the surgery. The post-operative care and physical therapy really helped, and now he is looking forward to swimming again.
Was this helpful?1
1Ioana Annis in Cincinnati, OH – Sep 22, 2017
Dr. Michelle Andrews, MD
Reply
Flag Comment
My experience with two knee replacements by Dr. Andrews , 2006 and 2016, has been remarkable. She is compassionate as well as highly skillful. Other professionals (x-ray techs, nurses, anesthesiologist) all remarked to me how exacting and careful she is. She explains what she's doing and why she does it, listened to the issues/concerns I had, giving me her total attention. I wouldn't hesitate recommending her to other family members or friends, knowing they would get expert care.
Was this helpful?
Larry Brubaker in Bethel, OH – Sep 20, 2017
Dr. Michelle Andrews, MD
Reply
Flag Comment
My experience was with Jessica Pykosz, PA-C. I would go back to her in a second. She was wonderful.
She was knowledgeable, kind and caring. I felt she genuinely cared about my pain and problem. She consulted with Dr. Andrews on my plan for care and it worked out wonderfully. Jessica was just the BEST! I would highly recommend both Dr. Andrews and Jessica. The whole experience made me very happy.
Thank You,
Donna H.
Was this helpful?
Donna H. in Batavia, OH – Sep 14, 2017
Dr. Michelle Andrews, MD
Reply
Flag Comment
Dr. Andrews is the best! She has taken care of my shoulder, scoped my knee and done carpal tunnel release on both right and left hands! From diagnosis, surgery and recovery I have had superb care! Dr. Andrews and her team rock! Could not have asked for better!
Was this helpful?1
1Linda Scherer in Harrison, OH – Aug 28, 2017
Dr. Michelle Andrews, MD
Reply
Flag Comment
Simply the best orthopedic doctor in the metropolitan area in Cincinnati
Was this helpful?
Pedro trigueiros in Cincinnati – Aug 24, 2017
Dr. Michelle Andrews, MD
Reply
Flag Comment
She is probably the best doctor in Cincinnati. She listens to your needs and explains everything very well. She is kind, gentle, and extremely knowledgeable. I recommend her highly! Would not let anyone else work on me!!!!
Was this helpful?
Linda Gates in Fairfield Ohio – Aug 11, 2017
Dr. Michelle Andrews, MD
Reply
Flag Comment
Dr. Andrews was my first choice for my left shoulder rotator cuff; she treated me for the same problem on the right shoulder 11 years ago with great results. I was able to get an appointment easily, completed the diagnostic work-up and had surgery. Her explanation and illustration of my shoulder problems helped me understand what would happen during surgery and why PT was so important. I'm now back to all my normal activities, pain-free-thanks to Dr. Andrews and my therapist Marie Clarke.
Was this helpful?1
1Pamela Popp in Ft. Thomas, KY – Aug 08, 2017
Dr. Michelle Andrews, MD
Reply
Flag Comment
Easy to talk to
Was this helpful?
Gail Gardner in Fairfield, OH – Aug 03, 2017
Dr. Michelle Andrews, MD
Reply
Flag Comment
Dr. Andrews is smart, caring, and a very skilled knee and shoulder orthopedic surgeon. She really cares about not only the surgery, but her patient's progress after surgery. The time she takes with patients is so much more than other physicians.
Was this helpful?
cincinnati, oh – Jul 23, 2017
Dr. Michelle Andrews, MD
Reply
Flag Comment
My wife, Rose Mary, is in late stage dementia. When i talked opiate pain relief versus a knee replacement, She would not do knee replacement. Understood. Then she told me, "What difference does it make?" Obviously Andrews did not think my wife was aware enough to understand. On the way home, Rose Mary looked at me and asked: "Am I dying?" We are going elsewhere and are very pleased with the Tri-Heath doctor we see. Andrews does not deserve accolades, but need dementia education.
Was this helpful?1
1Walt Schaefer in West Chester, OH – Jun 18, 2017
Dr. Michelle Andrews, MD
Reply
Flag Comment
Dr Andrews did a knee replacement for me. My results have been excellent. Dr. Andrews is efficient and businesslike yet I feel she is genuinely interested in you and your successful outcome. Took the time to answer my questions. Will have to have my other knee replaced in the future and I will be returning to Dr. Andrews.
Was this helpful?
James in Cincinnati, OH – Jun 16, 2017
Dr. Michelle Andrews, MD
Reply
Flag Comment
Dr. Andrews is an outstanding physician and surgeon who has cared for me and my family for many years. She is always professional and caring, keeping you completely informed on your medical condition. I have total trust in her and would highly recommend her to everyone.
Was this helpful?
Kathryn Bard in Cincinnati Oh – Jun 15, 2017
Dr. Michelle Andrews, MD
Reply
Flag Comment
Dr. Andrews is an excellent doctor and surgeon who has helped multiple members of my family with a variety of orthopedic problems.
Was this helpful?
May 28, 2017
Dr. Michelle Andrews, MD
Reply
Flag Comment
I would recommend Dr. Andrews to anyone and everyone. She is very thorough, explains conditions in detail and is an excellent surgeon. She sutures like a plastic surgeon! No detectable scars after arthroscopic knee surgery and my knee feels great.
Was this helpful?
Donna C in Montgomery, Ohio – May 20, 2017
Dr. Michelle Andrews, MD
Reply
Flag Comment
Reflecting on two TKRs in the last 4 years, I've come to appreciate Dr. Andrew's expertise as she saw to every detail of my surgeries resulting in two perfect knees! Dr. Andrews was not only concerned with the surgery. She educated me on my condition, treated me to avoid surgery, guided me in MY decision for surgery, helped me prepare actively for surgery, told me what to expect after surgery and what was expected of me for complete recovery. Now we rejoice together! She is a blessing!
Was this helpful?1
1Marita Hartel in Cincinnati, OH – May 19, 2017
Dr. Michelle Andrews, MD
Reply
Flag Comment
Dr.Michelle Andrews was a second opinion,and certainly a happy one. After seeing another Dr., who will remain nameless, I was told I would need a total shoulder replacement. Still in pain I went to Dr. Andrews who recommended I do a series Vitamin d 3 and dark cherry juice to relieve my pain and swelling and come back and see her in 5 weeks. I was amazed how much better I felt both physically and mentally after 5 weeks. She is amazing and certainly not scapel happy. Thanks Dr. Andrews.
Was this helpful?
Bud Walters in cincinnati, oh – May 17, 2017
Show more reviews