Dr. Josephine McAllister, MD

Dermatology •  Female • Age 42
  
Dr. McAllister
Accepting new patients

Dermatology Associates of Ithaca

3773 Luker Rd Cortland, NY 13045

Make an Appointment

Show Phone Number

Dr. Josephine McAllister, MD is a Dermatologist in Cortland, NY. Dr. McAllister has more experience with Dermatologic Oncology, Dermatologic Care, and Cosmetic Dermatology than other specialists in her area. She is affiliated with Cayuga Medical Center at Ithaca. She is accepting new patients. Be sure to call ahead with Dr. McAllister to book an appointment.


Dr. McAllister's Reviews

Likelihood to recommend Dr. McAllister

3.0

Based on 58 ratings

5 Stars
41.37931034482759%
(24)
4 Stars
5.172413793103448%
(3)
3 Stars
3.4482758620689653%
(2)
2 Stars
10.344827586206897%
(6)
1 Star
39.6551724137931%
(23)
healthgrades logo

Leave a review

How likely are you to recommend
Dr. McAllister?
(Select your rating)
What People Say About Dr. Josephine McAllister, MD
RecentHighestLowestMost Helpful
Reply Flag
Felt like a piece of meat in her office, a lab specimen. She seemed harried and extremely rushed and I felt super uncomfortable (which generally never happens in doctor's offices)
Was this helpful?
thumbs up icon option
thumbs down icon option
Cayuga Jill – May 13, 2020
×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Josephine McAllister, MD?
Reply Flag
Had three appts at Cortland never saw Dr. PA does all work. You go to specialist to see specialist! Did shave biopsy on spot size of pencil erasure. Precancerous- freeze area- swells up size of pea. Return want to do another shave biopsy. Should have done excision at this point to remove. Should have walked then. Gouged out area size of dime full skin deep. Margins still not clear. Wanted to do 4 mm punch biopsy. this would not have covered original area. Went to CMA dermatology for real Dr.
Was this helpful?
thumbs up icon option1
thumbs down icon option1
Steve S in Groton, NY – Jan 30, 2019
We are sorry to hear that you were dissatisfied...Read More
×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Josephine McAllister, MD?
Reply Flag
Josephine went above and beyond in taking care of my son Alex. He was hospitalized and she was very thorough and attentive in her treatment. She was extremely caring. Mark from her practice was also extremely diligent in his initial diagnosis of the issue. We had an excellent experience with this practice group.
Was this helpful?
thumbs up icon option2
thumbs down icon option1
Sep 20, 2018
×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Josephine McAllister, MD?
Reply Flag
My teenage daughter & I have been patients of Dr. McAllister's for several years now. As a registered nurse, I value Dr. McAllister's expertise & the thoroughness of her exam. Dr. McAllister & her team believe in empowering their patients by helping them understand how they can best care for their skin while explaining any necessary procedures and abnormal findings. Her office & staff are very professional, efficient & kind. Dr. McAllister has gained my trust & respect!
Was this helpful?
thumbs up icon option2
thumbs down icon option1
kelly Seaman in Trumansburg, NY – Aug 24, 2018
×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Josephine McAllister, MD?
Reply Flag
Reception very helpful and responsive to difficult scheduling. Careful assessmentbiopsy/pathology appropriate to concerns. Never feel practice dismisses potential concerns. Highly recommend this practice.
Was this helpful?
thumbs up icon option1
thumbs down icon option1
Kristin Stevens in Ithaca, NY – Jul 09, 2018
×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Josephine McAllister, MD?
Reply Flag
Drove from Bing to see Dr. McAllister & staff. Everyone's super friendly, confident & competent. Not sure why folks are complaining about Dr. A--when you see a specialist, PAs are the main point of care & contact w/the doctor overseeing every patient's care. She spent more than 10 minutes w/ me speaking about my concerns & explained everything thoroughly & respectfully. I see dozens of specialists a year for an unrelated health issue & Dr. A & her staff are by far the best; quick scheduling too
Was this helpful?
thumbs up icon option2
thumbs down icon option2
Alia Genera in Binghamton, NY – Feb 19, 2018
×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Josephine McAllister, MD?
Reply Flag
While at Dr McAllisters office I was pleasantly surprised with the staff, they are both friendly and helpful. The appointment times are on time and very thorough. My 3 page hand out was full of information about my visit: things to watch and further skin care recommendations. While I was in my appointment Dr McAllister stepped into the room and asked about my children and reminded me the importance of not only protecting myself from the sun but my children also. I'm very happy with my experience
Was this helpful?
thumbs up icon option
thumbs down icon option
Ithaca, NY – Jun 30, 2017
×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Josephine McAllister, MD?
Reply Flag
When scheduling an appointment be sure to ask if you will actually see the doctor. I naively assumed, as a returning patient with a history of pre-cancerous moles, that when I made an appointment at my family doctor's urging that I would be examined by Dr. McAllister herself. Instead, physician's assistant removed 2 moles for biopsy (total charge $1,100 including lab fees), and I never saw the doctor. In and out in 20 minutes , but I don't have a lot of confidence in the thoroughness of my exam.
Was this helpful?
thumbs up icon option4
thumbs down icon option1
Ithaca, NY – Mar 26, 2017
×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Josephine McAllister, MD?
Reply
Cannot stress enough how hard you should strive to avoid this practice and this doctor. One of the worst I've ever been to. She spends about 35 seconds with her patients and has her assistants do most of her work. She treated me very rudely and its clear she's just in it for the money. Stay away!
Was this helpful?
thumbs up icon option7
thumbs down icon option2
Southlake – Feb 15, 2017
×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Josephine McAllister, MD?
Reply Flag
Dr. McAllister runs her office like a factory. You see her for two minutes and/or only see the PA. Every time I have an appointment she ends up doing a biopsy--even on a pre-existing skin condition that I pointed out to her and that clearly didn't need a biopsy. She took the practice over from an excellent dermatologist. What a the standards in this office have fallen so much. I won't be back.
Was this helpful?
thumbs up icon option5
thumbs down icon option1
Ithaca, NY – Jan 17, 2017
×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Josephine McAllister, MD?
Reply Flag
Outstanding doctor! When one has been diagnosed with melanoma, one needs the very best dermatologist. Joshephine McAllister is that doctor. Since her arrival in Ithaca, I have been Dr. McAllister’s patient. Her office is not only run very efficiently, but also the personnel are warm and generous with their time. Dr. McAllister’s educational background and training are excellent. She brings her depth of knowledge and her surgical expertise to her patients in a very calm, caring manner.
Was this helpful?
thumbs up icon option
thumbs down icon option1
jam in Ithaca, NY – Nov 30, 2016
×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Josephine McAllister, MD?
Reply Flag
Dr McAllister is a thorough and very professional dermatologist. She has a personal warmth that eases my "white coat" fears and I feel very secure in her care and her diagnostic ability. I have been to many dermatologists in many places I've lived and have yet to see one who does not employ PAs for the preliminary assessment. (The PAs in her office are also very thorough and professional.) I am so surprised to see anything unfavorable written regarding Dr McAllister, her care or her staff.
Was this helpful?
thumbs up icon option1
thumbs down icon option
Betsy R in Ithaca, NY – Nov 29, 2016
×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Josephine McAllister, MD?
Reply Flag
Dr. McAllister was very friendly and super efficient. She examined me for skin problems While her assistant was entering what the doctor found in the computer. They told me what was wrong and what was OK and took biopsies and was out of there with confidence that I'd been well taken care of. I would recommend Dr. McAllister to anyone in the area with skin concerns. Excellent care.
Was this helpful?
thumbs up icon option2
thumbs down icon option
William G in Dryden, NY – Oct 26, 2016
×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Josephine McAllister, MD?
Reply Flag
Dr. McAllister is one of the worst doctor's I have ever been to. She was very impersonal and most of the work done in her office is done by her assistants. She was not helpful, and in fact I felt disrespected by the way she treated me. Would not recommend. Avoid this practice.
Was this helpful?
thumbs up icon option7
thumbs down icon option
Ithaca, NY – Sep 27, 2016
×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Josephine McAllister, MD?
Reply Flag
Dr. McAllister was very unpleasant. She did not listen to my needs and she appeared bothered by my questions. The staff at the office is very nice -- but I would not return.
Was this helpful?
thumbs up icon option12
thumbs down icon option3
Anonymous in Ithaca, NY – Mar 21, 2016
×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Josephine McAllister, MD?
Reply Flag
I went into the office for the first time today. The office was running on-schedule. Dr. McAllister spoke with me about my concerns and did a quick body scan for any abnormal-seeming moles (this was not the purpose of my visit), in addition to checking out my skin condition. We then spoke about possible methods of treatment for the skin condition I've been suffering from for years. After that, she let me know that her PA would be coming in to speak with me. Overall, a very pleasant experience.
Was this helpful?
thumbs up icon option4
thumbs down icon option3
Ithaca, NY – Feb 17, 2016
×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Josephine McAllister, MD?
Reply
She is a horrible physician. She charges patient or insurance co and has her PA see the patients! He has no experience at all! She also sent a bill for sending my medical records to another doctor! I have wasted my time getting incorrect medication for six months!! She knows its not legal to charge money for medical records when sending them to another physician! Nothing but a scam!! I guess she is banking up the money to pay for her medical school bills!
Was this helpful?
thumbs up icon option13
thumbs down icon option5
Sania in Ithaca, NY – Feb 12, 2016
×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Josephine McAllister, MD?
Reply Flag
I went for an annual skin check for the first time with Dr. McAllister and it turned into a nightmare. My appt was with her and she had her male PA come in to do my initial mole check without my knowledge or approval (I am a female). B/t the two of them they marked 7 spots with an 8 to be surgically removed. This was overkill for my first appt and I am wondering if they were trying to drive up my bill to insurance. Now I have seven scars and after four weeks of waiting the results were benign
Was this helpful?
thumbs up icon option10
thumbs down icon option2
Ithaca, NY – Jan 21, 2016
×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Josephine McAllister, MD?

Leave a review

How was your experience with Dr. McAllister?

About Me

At Dermatology Associates of Ithaca, we use a team-based approach to detect and treat problematic skin conditions.  As we often say, four eyes are better than two!  Utilizing the talents of multiple people who are specialized in different a...

Specialties

  • Dermatology
  • Cosmetic Dermatology
  • Dermatologic Surgery

Board Certifications

Education

2009
Harvard Medical School
Residency Hospital

Awards

Frequently Asked Questions

What other Dermatologists practice nearby?

What are Dr. Josephine McAllister, MD's top areas of care?

Where is Dr. Josephine McAllister, MD's office located?

Insurance Check

Search for your insurance provider

Dr. McAllister accepts

Accepted insurance can change. Please double-check when making an appointment.

(607) 257-1107

Dr. McAllister accepts the following insurance:

Aetna
Choice Plus POS II
Anthem
National (BlueCard) PPO
Blue Cross Blue Shield
Blue Card PPO
CareFirst Blue Cross Blue Shield
HealthyBlue 2.0
HealthyBlue Advantage
Cigna
Cigna HMO
Cigna PPO
Open Access Plus
CoreSource
EBS-RMSCO
EmblemHealth
Emblem Health
Empire Blue Cross Blue Shield
Empire Blue Cross Blue Shield HMO
Excellus BlueCross BlueShield
Excellus BlueCross BlueShield PPO
Fidelis Care
Highmark Blue Cross Blue Shield
Medicaid
MVP Health Care
MVP Health Care PPO
POMCO Group
UnitedHealthCare
United Healthcare
Universal American

Background Check

No malpractice claims found for New York
No disciplinary actions found for the years we collect data
No board actions found for the years we collect data
Learn more about background checks

Practice Areas

Dermatologic Oncology

Oncologists diagnose and treat cancers of the skin, including melanoma, basal cell carcinoma, and squamous cell carcinoma.

Typically treats 75% more than their peers

Based on claims data for 9 conditions and procedures

TreatmentsTreatment Frequency
Excision of Skin Lesion
very high
very high

Treatment Frequency

Dr. McAllister performs Excision of Skin Lesion more than 99% of their peers

Dr. McAllister performs this procedure more than 99% of their peers

Actinic Keratosis
very high
very high

Treatment Frequency

Dr. McAllister treats Actinic Keratosis more than 99% of their peers

Dr. McAllister treats this condition more than 99% of their peers

Excision of Skin Cancer
very high
very high

Treatment Frequency

Dr. McAllister performs Excision of Skin Cancer more than 92% of their peers

Dr. McAllister performs this procedure more than 92% of their peers

Dermatologic Care

Dermatologists diagnose, treat and screen for conditions affecting the skin, including skin cancer, psoriasis, eczema, acne, rosacea, and hair loss.

Typically treats 82% more than their peers

Based on claims data for 28 conditions and procedures

TreatmentsTreatment Frequency
Skin Infections
very high
very high

Treatment Frequency

Dr. McAllister treats Skin Infections more than 100% of their peers

Dr. McAllister treats this condition more than 100% of their peers

Ringworm
very high
very high

Treatment Frequency

Dr. McAllister treats Ringworm more than 100% of their peers

Dr. McAllister treats this condition more than 100% of their peers

Excision of Skin Lesion
very high
very high

Treatment Frequency

Dr. McAllister performs Excision of Skin Lesion more than 99% of their peers

Dr. McAllister performs this procedure more than 99% of their peers

Cosmetic Dermatology

Cosmetic dermatologists diagnose and treat condition of the skin that affect appearance, such as age spots, wrinkles, unwanted hair, and acne scars.

Typically treats 71% more than their peers

Based on claims data for 8 conditions and procedures

TreatmentsTreatment Frequency
Skin Discoloration
very high
very high

Treatment Frequency

Dr. McAllister treats Skin Discoloration more than 99% of their peers

Dr. McAllister treats this condition more than 99% of their peers

Excision of Skin Lesion
very high
very high

Treatment Frequency

Dr. McAllister performs Excision of Skin Lesion more than 99% of their peers

Dr. McAllister performs this procedure more than 99% of their peers

Destruction of Benign Skin Lesion
very high
very high

Treatment Frequency

Dr. McAllister performs Destruction of Benign Skin Lesion more than 98% of their peers

Dr. McAllister performs this procedure more than 98% of their peers

Mohs Surgery

Mohs surgery is a procedure that treats some types of skin cancer by removing a precise amount of tissue in order to remove cancer cells while sparing as much healthy tissue as possible.

Typically treats 68% more than their peers

Based on claims data for 2 conditions and procedures

TreatmentsTreatment Frequency
Excision, Shaving, or Destruction of Skin and Subcutaneous Tissue (incl. Mohs Micrographic Surgery), Tissue Transfer
very high
very high

Treatment Frequency

Dr. McAllister performs Excision, Shaving, or Destruction of Skin and Subcutaneous Tissue (incl. Mohs Micrographic Surgery), Tissue Transfer more than 88% of their peers

Dr. McAllister performs this procedure more than 88% of their peers

Destruction of Malignant Skin Lesion
normal
normal

Treatment Frequency

Dr. McAllister performs Destruction of Malignant Skin Lesion more than 48% of their peers

Dr. McAllister performs this procedure more than 48% of their peers

Hide other practice areas

Check Dr. McAllister's experience treating your condition or procedure

Dr. McAllister's conditions and procedures:

  • Abscess or Cyst Drainage or Aspiration
  • Abscess or Fluid Incision and Drainage
  • Acne
  • Acne Surgery
  • Actinic Keratosis
  • Adjacent Tissue Transfer
  • Athlete's Foot
  • Atopic Dermatitis (Eczema)
  • Autoimmune Diseases
  • Basal Cell Carcinoma
  • Benign Tumor
  • Biopsy
  • Biopsy of Affected Tissue
  • Birthmark
  • Boil
  • Botox® Injection
  • Cancer
  • Candidiasis of Skin and Nails
  • Carcinoma in Situ of Skin
  • Cellulitis
  • Cold Sore
  • Dermatitis
  • Destruction of Benign Skin Lesion
  • Destruction of Malignant Skin Lesion
  • Destruction of Penile Lesion
  • Excessive Sweating
  • Excision
  • Excision of Benign Skin Lesion
  • Excision of Cyst
  • Excision of Lipoma
  • Excision of Skin Cancer
  • Excision of Skin Lesion
  • Excision, Shaving, or Destruction of Skin and Subcutaneous Tissue (incl. Mohs Micrographic Surgery), Tissue Transfer
  • Excisional Biopsy
  • Facial Skin Cancer
  • Folliculitis
  • Foot Conditions
  • Fungal Infections
  • Fungal Nail Infection
  • Genital Herpes
  • Genital Warts
  • Hair Loss
  • Herpes Simplex Infection
  • Hidradenitis
  • Hives
  • Impetigo
  • Intertrigo
  • Itchy Skin
  • Jock Itch
  • Keloid Scar
  • Lichen Planus
  • Lipomas
  • Lyme Disease
  • Melanoma
  • Merkel Cell Carcinoma
  • Mole Removal
  • Moles (Benign Skin Lesions)
  • Non-Cosmetic Chemodenervation
  • Non-Melanoma Skin Cancer
  • Pemphigoid
  • Pigmented Basal Cell Carcinoma
  • Plantar Wart
  • Poison Ivy, Poison Oak, or Poison Sumac Poisoning
  • Psoriasis
  • Rash
  • Ringworm
  • Rosacea
  • Scabies
  • Seborrheic Dermatitis
  • Seborrheic Keratosis
  • Shaving of Skin Lesion
  • Shingles
  • Skin Biopsy
  • Skin Cancer
  • Skin Cancer Removal
  • Skin Discoloration
  • Skin Infections
  • Skin Surgery
  • Skin Tag Removal
  • Squamous Cell Carcinoma
  • Tinea Versicolor
  • Varicose Veins
  • Wart Removal
  • Warts

Locations

Dermatology Associates of Ithaca

Dermatology Associates of Ithaca - Cortland3773 Luker Rd Cortland, NY 13045
1
  • Call
  • Fax
  • Hours
    • Mon: 7:30am - 5:00pm
    • Tue: 7:30am - 5:00pm
    • Wed: 7:30am - 5:00pm
    • Thu: closed
    • Fri: 7:30am - 5:00pm
    • Sat: closed
    • Sun: closed
  • Directions
Robert T Horn Jr, MD2333 N Triphammer Rd Ste 203 Ithaca, NY 14850
2
  • Call
  • Fax
  • Hours
    • Mon: 7:30am - 5:00pm
    • Tue: 7:30am - 5:00pm
    • Wed: 7:30am - 5:00pm
    • Thu: 7:30am - 5:00pm
    • Fri: 7:30am - 5:00pm
    • Sat: closed
    • Sun: closed
  • Directions

Affiliated Hospitals

Check the quality of care at hospitals where Dr. McAllister treats patients.

Learn more

Cayuga Medical Center at Ithaca

Ithaca, NY

71% Patient experience rating, 2% higher than the national average