Dr. Jeremy Mathis, DO

Orthopedic Surgery • Male • Age 46

Accepting new patients

Shoulder/Upper Arm, and More

OrthoNeuro

1313 Olentangy River Rd Columbus, OH 43212

Make an Appointment

(614) 890-6555

Dr. Jeremy Mathis, DO is a Orthopedic Surgery Specialist in Columbus, OH. Dr. Mathis has more experience with Shoulder/Upper Arm than other specialists in his area. He is affiliated with medical facilities such as Dublin Methodist Hospital and OhioHealth Grant Medical Center. He is accepting new patients. Be sure to call ahead with Dr. Mathis to book an appointment.

Compare Providers

Quickly compare more Orthopedic Surgery Specialists in your area

Providers within 25 miles Providers with 4+ star ratings Providers who offer telehealth View all Orthopedic Surgery

At a Glance

Explains Conditions Well
Patients said this doctor explains conditions well. • See reviews
Practices at Top Hospital
Joint Replacement Excellence Award™ • See hospitals
Recent Reviews
Reviews made in the last 30 days. • See reviews

Experience and Background Checks

Experience

Background

Background Check

Healthgrades does not collect malpractice claims information for Ohio

No disciplinary actions found for the years we collect data

No board actions found for the years we collect data

Learn more about background checks

Frequently Treated by Dr. Mathis

Based on treatment records, we have identified the following as areas of care that Dr. Mathis treats more often than their peers. If you are unsure whether Dr. Mathis treats other conditions, please contact the office at (614) 890-6555.

Shoulder/Upper Arm

Shoulder and upper arm conditions include arthritis, bursitis, rotator cuff injuries, and dislocations, with treatment options such as surgery or physical therapy.Compare with other Shoulder/Upper Arm specialists.

Dr. Mathis typically treats 63% more often than similar doctors

Based on claims data for 6 conditions and procedures

Treatments

Shoulder Disorders

Shoulder Tendinitis and Tenosynovitis

Arthroscopic Shoulder Surgery

Rotator Cuff Tear

Normal Frequency

High Frequency

Very High Frequency

Dr. Mathis

Similar Providers

Check Dr. Mathis' experience treating your condition or procedure

Dr. Mathis' conditions and procedures:

ACL Surgery
Adhesive Capsulitis
Anterior Cruciate Ligament (ACL) or Posterior Cruciate Ligament (PCL) Tear
Arthroscopic Shoulder Surgery
Baker’s Cyst
Broken Arm
Bursitis
Clavicle Fracture
Complications of Joint Prosthesis
Foot and Ankle Fracture Treatment, Closed
Fracture
Fracture Care
Glenoid Labrum Tear
Joint Pain
Knee and Leg Fracture and Dislocation Treatment
Knee Arthroscopy
Knee Dislocation
Knee Disorders
Knee Sprain
Knee Surgery
Medial Collateral Ligament (MCL) Sprain
Neck Muscle Strain
Neck Strain (incl. Whiplash Injury)
Osteoarthritis of Hip and Thigh
Osteoarthritis of Knee
Osteoarthritis of Shoulder
Osteoarthritis of Spine
Osteochondritis Dissecans
Patellofemoral Pain Syndrome or Knee Pain
Peripheral Nerve Disorders
Rotator Cuff Surgery
Rotator Cuff Tear
Runner's Knee
Shoulder Dislocation
Shoulder Dislocation Treatment
Shoulder Disorders
Shoulder Fracture and Dislocation Treatment
Shoulder Fracture Treatment
Shoulder Impingement Syndrome
Shoulder Tendinitis and Tenosynovitis
Sprains and Strains (incl. Muscle Tear)
Steroid Injection

Insurance Check

Search for your insurance provider

Dr. Mathis accepts

Accepted insurance can change. Please double-check when making an appointment.

(614) 890-6555

Dr. Mathis accepts the following insurance:

Aetna: Aetna HMO; Choice Plus POS II
Anthem: Balanced Blue Access-OH PPO; Blue Access Options for ERC Health-OH PPO; Blue Access Options-OH PPO; Blue Access-OH PPO; Blue Preferred Plus-OH POS; Blue Preferred-OH EPO; Blue Preferred-OH HMO; Blue Preferred-OH POS; Blue Traditional-OH; Bronze Blue Access-OH PPO; Bronze Blue Access-OH PPO Plus; Bronze Pathway Group-OH HMO; Bronze Pathway X-OH HMO; Bronze Pathway-OH HMO; Catastrophic Pathway X-OH HMO; Catastrophic Pathway-OH HMO; Gold Blue Access-OH PPO; Gold Pathway Group-OH HMO; Gold Pathway X-OH HMO; Gold Pathway-OH HMO; Lumenos Plans-OH; National (BlueCard Basic) PPO; National (BlueCard) PPO; Ohio Med Plan-OH; Pathway-OH HMO; Platinum Blue Access-OH PPO; Platinum Pathway Group-OH HMO; Silver Blue Access-OH PPO; Silver Blue Access-OH PPO Plus; Silver Pathway Group-OH HMO; Silver Pathway X-OH HMO; Silver Pathway-OH HMO; The Christ Hospital Health Network (TCHHN)-OH; Trihealth HD80-OH
Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield: Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield HMO; Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield PPO
Blue Cross Blue Shield: Blue Card PPO
CareFirst Blue Cross Blue Shield: HealthyBlue 2.0; HealthyBlue Advantage
Centene
Cigna: Cigna HMO; Cigna PPO; Open Access Plus
Coventry Health Care
First Health (Coventry Health Care): First Health (Coventry Health Care) PPO
Humana: Choice Care PPO
Medicaid
Medical Mutual of Ohio
UnitedHealthCare: PacifiCare; United Healthcare
WellCare: WellCare PPO
WellPoint
Worker's Compensation: Worker's Compensation WC

Dr. Mathis' Reviews

Likelihood to recommend Dr. Mathis

4.8

Based on 73 ratings

5 Stars	90.41095890410959%	(66)
4 Stars	6.8493150684931505%	(5)
3 Stars	0%	(0)
2 Stars	0%	(0)
1 Star	2.73972602739726%	(2)

RecentHighestLowestMost Helpful

Reply Flag

Dr. Mathis did both of my knee surgeries. He knows his stuff and has a good bedside manner. He has always been my orthopedic dr accept for my back surgery and I won’t go to anyone accept the dr. At Orthoneuro.

What went well

Appointment scheduling
Office environment
Staff friendliness
Appointment wasn't rushed
Listened & answered questions
Explained conditions well

What could be improved

No results

Was this helpful?

Janet E – Oct 29, 2020

×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Jeremy Mathis, DO?

Reply Flag

Friendly, responsive, efficient and trustworthy.

What went well

Appointment scheduling
Office environment
Staff friendliness
Appointment wasn't rushed
Listened & answered questions
Explained conditions well
Trusted the provider's decisions

What could be improved

Long wait times

Was this helpful?

Rich – Oct 07, 2020

×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Jeremy Mathis, DO?

Reply Flag

Dr Mathis did my shoulder surgery and he was very personable from the start. After surgery and physical therapy was completed I was back to work with full function and no pain. I highly recommend Dr. Jeremy Mathis

What went well

No results

What could be improved

No results

Was this helpful?

W.R – May 25, 2020

×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Jeremy Mathis, DO?

Reply Flag

He was not my original doctor after my injury but my second opinion. I was frustrated with original doctor telling me we would discuss everything later. I saw Dr.Mathis a month after my injury and come to find out I was walking on a fracture. Dr. Mathis was very straightforward and came up with a course of treatment on my first visit. I would recommend him to anyone.

What went well

Appointment scheduling
Office environment
Staff friendliness
Wait times
Appointment wasn't rushed
Listened & answered questions
Explained conditions well
Trusted the provider's decisions

What could be improved

No results

Was this helpful?

May 17, 2018

×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Jeremy Mathis, DO?

Underwent a rotator repair with biceps tenodesis in June 2016. Immediately after surgery I was practically pain free. The worst of recovery was easily managed with a bit of Tylenol. Can't recommend Dr. Mathis enough if you are in need of orthopedic care. Nine months post surgery I have regained full range of motion and I'm pain free.

What went well

No results

What could be improved

No results

Was this helpful?

Geoff in Dublin, OH – Apr 12, 2017

×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Jeremy Mathis, DO?

Reply Flag

I had my 5th knee surgery done by Dr. Mathis. He did the best job out of the 3 doctors to operate on my knees. I only wish he was in my insurance plans network. I just injured my shoulder and I believe I'm going to need surgery right away and I REALLY wanted Dr. Mathis to do the procedure. He is an awesome surgeon and a great person in general. His staff is awesome also!

What went well

No results

What could be improved

No results

Was this helpful?

Mike Casey in Columbus, OH – Mar 16, 2017

×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Jeremy Mathis, DO?

Reply Flag

We have had multiple broken bones with our three boys and ALWAYS take them to see Dr. Mathis. He is great with them and helps explain things to me that I understand.

What went well

No results

What could be improved

No results

Was this helpful?

H Byrne in Columbus, OH – Feb 03, 2017

×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Jeremy Mathis, DO?

Leave a review

How was your experience with Dr. Mathis?

About Me

Care Philosophy

"Whether you are a student-athlete, professional athlete, a weekend warrior, or have never played sports in your life, I am grateful that I can help...Read more

Biography

Dr. Mathis believes in discussing options with his patients to determine the best course of treatment- surgically or not. He volunteers as an...Read more