Mount Carmel West

65%

Patients that would definitely recommend
5% lower than the national average


Mount Carmel West is a medical facility located in Columbus, OH. This hospital has been recognized for Cranial Neurosurgery Excellence Award™, General Surgery Excellence Award™, and more.

Awards

Healthgrades awards tell you which hospitals deliver superior quality care. Healthgrades evaluates hospital performance using objective quality measures including clinical outcomes and patient safety, as well as patient experience.

Learn more about our awards methodology

Specialty Clinical Quality Awards

Cranial Neurosurgery Excellence Award™ (2020, 2019, 2018)

Superior clinical outcomes in cranial neurosurgery

General Surgery Excellence Award™ (2020)

Superior clinical outcomes in bowel obstruction treatment, colorectal surgeries, gallbladder removal, esophageal/stomach surgeries, and small intestine surgeries

Neurosciences Excellence Award™ (2020, 2019, 2018)

Superior clinical outcomes in stroke care and neurosurgery

Stroke Care Excellence Award™ (2020, 2018)

Superior clinical outcomes in the care and treatment of stroke

America’s 100 Best Hospitals for Stroke Care Award™ (2019)

Superior clinical outcomes in the care and treatment of stroke

Safety Ratings

How well a hospital safeguards patients from potential complications

No events relating to foreign objects left in body during a surgery or procedure

4 ratings were worse than expected

1 rating was better than expected

  • Accidental cut, puncture, perforation or hemorrhage during medical care

8 ratings were as expected

  • Death in procedures where mortality is usually very low
  • Pressure sores or bed sores acquired in the hospital
  • Death following a serious complication after surgery
  • Catheter-related bloodstream infections acquired at the hospital
  • Hip fracture following surgery
  • Excessive bruising or bleeding as a consequence of a procedure or surgery
  • Deep blood clots in the lungs or legs following surgery
  • Breakdown of abdominal incision site
Learn more about patient safety ratings

Hospital Quality

Clinical Ratings

Research hospital performance and talk to your doctor about what's right for you

Data Source

Patient Experience

Patient experience measures tell you how patients felt about the care they received at the hospital. These measures are based on the Hospital Consumer Assessment of Healthcare Providers and Systems (HCAHPS) survey data from the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS).

Learn more about patient experience
65%

Patients who gave a rating of 9 or 10
4% lower than the national average

65%

Would definitely recommend
5% lower than the national average

Mount Carmel West

National Average

Communication with doctors

Percent of patients who said that doctors always listened to them and explained things well

100%50%0%78%81%

Communication with nurses

Percent of patients who said that nurses always listened to them and explained things well

100%50%0%76%78%

Communication about medicines

Percent of patients who said that staff always explained medicines before giving them to patients

100%50%0%57%63%

Discharge Information

Percent of patients who said they were given information about recovering at home

100%50%0%87%84%

Care Transition

Percent of patients who said they understood their care needs when they left the hospital

100%50%0%49%53%

Responsiveness of hospital staff

Percent of patients who said they always received help quickly from hospital staff

100%50%0%56%66%

Mount Carmel West

National Average

Quietness

Percent of patients who said the area around their rooms was always kept quiet at night

100%50%0%48%60%

Cleanliness

Percent of patients who said their room and bathroom were always kept clean

100%50%0%59%73%

Providers

Provider Reviews

Nancy W. Sep 24 2020

Review for Dr. Straka

She is absolutely wonderful!!! Love her! She helped my young daughter who has breast cancer in so many ways!!!! She is the answer to my prayers! And I am so thankful for her and her staff!!!

Mia Sep 12 2020

Review for Dr. Grenade

Jane R. Sep 12 2020

Review for Dr. Paes

Dr Coyle listens to me and works well with me and adresses my needs. She keeps up on latest health care info.

Marianne Steger Sep 11 2020

Review for Dr. Coyle

Dr Toohey is compassionate and thorough. I would recommend her and this practice to anyone.

Barb E Sep 11 2020

Review for Dr. Toohey

Experience was wonderful. She really listens and collaborates with the patient to determine the best course of treatment

Sep 11 2020

Review for Dr. Briones

just kind of a d i c k the whole time. find someone else

Sep 10 2020

Review for Dr. Gianakopoulos

Actually listens to you

Laura Beemiller Sep 10 2020

Review for Dr. Cox

Very thoughtful and knowledgeable. Always even keeled and helpful.

DC Sep 10 2020

Review for Dr. Lane

Dr Hannallah performed my Laminectomy 6 weeks ago. He’s a great surgeon. I couldn’t be more pleased with his expertise. He listens and is kind. I highly recommend him.

Randy Kaderly Sep 09 2020

Review for Dr. Hannallah

He was a great doctor. He helped me with my problems. He explains everything well and is not rushed. Very nice doctor. He listens and answers your questions. I highly recommend Dr. Khanduja. My surgery went Very Well. Thank you.

Sep 09 2020

Review for Dr. Khanduja

Dr. Idris thorough, engaging, and competent. I left his office feeling much better that he listened to my concerns, provided solid advice, and had a plan of care.

M. Judd Sep 09 2020

Review for Dr. Idris

Always takes as much time as needed to talk with you and to find out what he needs to give you the correct information about any treament.

bert caulley Sep 06 2020

Review for Dr. Mengesha

I have been a patient of Dr. Rittenberry's for several years and she is an excellent endocrinologist. Her staff is professional and very thoughtful. I drive a long way for an appointment with her and would not consider switching to a physician nearer my home.

M. H. F. Sep 04 2020

Review for Dr. Rittenberry

Dr. Brown was amazing. He worked very quickly to get me in and ease my mind through it all. The surgery went perfect. Thank you!

Sep 04 2020

Review for Dr. Brown

Very informative, great bedside manner answered all my questions told me stuff I didn't know. Ended up treating both my thyroid cancer and diabetes. Really like him and my other doctors are impressed.

Sep 04 2020

Review for Dr. Anderson

Dr. Popp has always been a super Doctor. I recommend him to everyone and anyone that needs an upper extremity consult. 5 star kinda guy.

Brenda Myers Sep 04 2020

Review for Dr. Popp

I was more comfortable n my entire appointment went well. She was at her best.

Radhika Ramalingam Sep 03 2020

Review for Dr. Briones

Elen Sep 03 2020

Review for Dr. Cox

....my visit with Dr. Pap ,was positive,he was very thorough and empathetic towards my situation, he basically care planned as he spoke about it! I recommend him....

Marilyn A.Page R.N Sep 03 2020

Review for Dr. Pap

Sep 02 2020

Review for Dr. Teague

Very friendly and is genuinely involved in your care. He is very knowledgeable and easy to talk to.

Jasmine Sep 02 2020

Review for Dr. Mitchell

Rebecca McCarthy Sep 02 2020

Review for Dr. Zerick

E Younger Sep 02 2020

Review for Dr. Wing

Dr. khanduja and his experience is why I was referred to him. He has a way of explaining that is easy to understand. He listens & educates his patients. Never once did I feel uncomfortable. I recommend Dr. Khanduja for all your colon/rectal concerns.

Tammie Lowry Sep 01 2020

Review for Dr. Khanduja

Dr. Parker is caring and thorough during visits.

Nothing Aug 30 2020

Review for Dr. Parker

Emmabess Aug 30 2020

Review for Dr. Paes

Dr. Saribalas Is excellent...caring and compassionate. His staff is friendly and helpful.

R A Aug 29 2020

Review for Dr. Saribalas

Heather Blackburn Aug 29 2020

Review for Dr. Madan

very good dr.

jeff britton Aug 29 2020

Review for Dr. Tanzer

Aug 28 2020

Review for Dr. Searcy

She is always focused on your issues and tries to improve your current state with whatever resources she can.

Crystal buchholz Aug 28 2020

Review for Dr. Butz

Beth. G. Aug 27 2020

Review for Dr. Coyle

Susan Aug 26 2020

Review for Dr. Searcy

She really listens and takes w patients. She wants to know you personally. She is always kind. She does wonderful w my teenage autistic son as a patient also!

Aug 26 2020

Review for Dr. Sun

I just moved to Columbus and Dr. Patel was recommended as a primary care physician. I was very pleased, her staff was very helpful and professional. My initial visit was not rushed, I felt listened to and I am very happy that I found a doctor that I feel confident in.

Aug 26 2020

Review for Dr. Patel

Yes, very curious and took time to listen to me. Took the time to get to know me and my issues as this was my first visit

Dan Hollingsworth Aug 26 2020

Review for Dr. Sun

Dr. Toohey is a fantastic doctor, down to earth and actually cares about you. I have NEVER had to sit and wait past my appointment time and I have been seeing her for years.

Corey Aug 25 2020

Review for Dr. Toohey

Teresa M. Aug 25 2020

Review for Dr. Dhawale

Michael Torres Aug 24 2020

Review for Dr. Blair

I have been a patient at this practice for a long time and Dr Makadia and Rhonda have always been very kind to me and my family. They have always given me the best of care.

Aug 24 2020

Review for Dr. Makadia

Dr. Makadia is one of the best doctors in the city. His knowledge and expertise is top notch. Bonus points for kindness, patience, and a great sense of humor!

J. Turner Aug 22 2020

Review for Dr. Makadia

Dr.Hughes has been my family physician for 10+ years. She is knowledgeable, thorough and professional. Very easy to talk with her and I'm grateful she listens.

Cynthia B. Aug 22 2020

Review for Dr. Hughes

The doctors and staff here are always pleasant and helpful and appointments are quick and prompt. I always leave knowing that I've been well taken care of. Staff is top-notch! Dr. Lora Brown is caring and thorough!

Richard Welch Aug 22 2020

Review for Dr. Brown

Amazing and genuinely concerned about her patients.Excellent!

Mona Hales Aug 22 2020

Review for Dr. Labrec-Salmons

It's pleasant clean and great time

Kip chatman Aug 21 2020

Review for Dr. Jones-Lopez

Dr Amico is very thorough with her patients. She works hard to improve the care and health of those she serves. Great doctor!

Lynette Costner Aug 21 2020

Review for Dr. Amico

Great skilled Doctor. Patient for 25 years.

Aug 20 2020

Review for Dr. Wolf

Anonymous Aug 20 2020

Review for Dr. Richey

Dr Byrge told me honestly that a carotid endarterectomy was too risky for me. A surgeon who makes his living doing surgery advised against this surgery. Such honesty I appreciate. I am so thankful he moved his practice to Columbus. This guy is awesome!

Deirdre Beth Aug 20 2020

Review for Dr. Byrge

Because she's really know what she doing

Not at all Aug 20 2020

Review for Dr. Parker

Aug 20 2020

Review for Dr. Wolf

Todd Nelson Aug 20 2020

Review for Dr. Hua

K. King Aug 20 2020

Review for Dr. Anderson

Aug 19 2020

Review for Dr. Wolf

Great Dt

Aug 19 2020

Review for Dr. Makadia

Somehow combines youthful enthusiasm with experience and knowledge to provide excellent care with no delays. He is awesome!

Frankie Aug 18 2020

Review for Dr. Fate

mary Aug 17 2020

Review for Dr. Brown

Aug 16 2020

Review for Dr. Anderson

First visit. He was friendly, listened well, and provided helpful information and education. Made referral for an issue he thought should be looked at by specialist. Also gave referral for NFP OBGYN. So glad I went.

Aug 16 2020

Review for Dr. Casey

I have been fortunate enough to have been a patient of Dr Huston for over 15 years. She is an amazing doctor who always takes the time to explain and discuss my health concerns and diagnosis. I would highly recommend Doctor Huston.

Natalie Roberts Aug 16 2020

Review for Dr. Huston

I've been seeing Dr. Cox for a few years. She's always professional and explains everything thoroughly. Front office staff always polite and helpful and when I had scheduling conflicts they worked with me and took the time to find an appointment time that would work for me.

Robby Simpson Aug 16 2020

Review for Dr. Cox

I’ve seen Dr. Coyle for almost 7 years. She’s knowledgeable, compassionate, competent, and remembers personal details. She’s wonderful and I highly recommend her.

Aug 16 2020

Review for Dr. Coyle

Always excellent for the last 8 years.

John Hawn Aug 15 2020

Review for Dr. Ottaviano

I have being seeing Dr Schreck for about 2 years now. She always takes time to listen to my concerns, is so friendly & easy to talk to. She is also very thorough & responsive. I highly recommend her!

Aug 15 2020

Review for Dr. Schreck

Very professional

Aug 15 2020

Review for Dr. Huston

A very warm and welcoming atmosphere ??. Pay very close attention to detail. Really care about the their patients

Aug 14 2020

Review for Dr. Jones-Lopez

Well and helpful

Gerald Price Aug 14 2020

Review for Dr. Anderson

Olivia Aug 14 2020

Review for Dr. Quinlin

April gutter Aug 13 2020

Review for Dr. Qazi

I was very impressed with his knowledge, caring and understanding of how I was feeling.

Aug 13 2020

Review for Dr. Pap

I highly recommend Dr. Schumacher to everyone looking for a primary family Doctor. He has been my primary doctor for over 30yrs. He never rush through your appointment.

Marcia Broadnax Aug 11 2020

Review for Dr. Schumacher

I had kidney failure 13 years ago, I was in Mount Carmel East and Dr. Kovach helped get me back on my feet. A wonderful doctor.

William Aug 11 2020

Review for Dr. Kovach

Lisa Joy Aug 10 2020

Review for Dr. Hannallah

Excellent physician. He listens and always knows the best care

Aug 10 2020

Review for Dr. Murray

I have been going to Dr. Gtandinetti for about 15 years. He's a people person and spends the time to care which is rare.

Edward Quince Aug 09 2020

Review for Dr. Grandinetti

Very friendly and knowledgeable, the staff is great

Aug 08 2020

Review for Dr. Wilson

Dr. Jipa is very attentive, listens and addresses all of my concerns. I would highly recommend him.

Mary Talbert Aug 08 2020

Review for Dr. Jipa

Dr. Labrec-Salmons is extremely personable and genuinely concerned about the whole person, not just the immediate issue. She doesn't use guilt to motivate when a change is needed, but sincere concern and encouragement.

Lyn R Aug 08 2020

Review for Dr. Labrec-Salmons

Dr. Flowers is a very good doctor. She always listens and explains thing thoroughly. Glad to have her as my primary care physician.

JoAnna Aug 07 2020

Review for Dr. Flowers

Dr Wilson is very attentive to patient feedback and concerns

Aug 07 2020

Review for Dr. Wilson

Aug 07 2020

Review for Dr. Steensen

Aug 07 2020

Review for Dr. Kunz

Did not like this doctor, he just did not seem to care, he did not follow through with answers to questions. He just was behind his computer. I felt my visit was just a waste of my time.

Aug 06 2020

Review for Dr. Lane

Gary Young Aug 06 2020

Review for Dr. Parker

Dr. Politi replaced my knee. I was able to get an appointment quickly and had the surgery a week and one-half later. I am still in the recovery stage but am very pleased with the results. I highly recommend him. Bertie Rice

Bertie Rice Aug 06 2020

Review for Dr. Politi

Had total hip replacement also had three pins removed that had been in place over forty years! I am very happy with Dr Gittins and his staff, would highly recommend to anyone needing hip replacement.

T. Willis Aug 06 2020

Review for Dr. Gittins

Sue Aug 06 2020

Review for Dr. Hodges

Yes, I would highly recommend Dr. Searcy. He did both of my catarac surgeries (complete with lens implants) and I see with 20/20 vision now - no glasses! So grateful and pleased that my checkups are handled with thorough testing to make sure we catch anything else that might creep up.

Teresa Aug 05 2020

Review for Dr. Searcy

Lt. Col. Richard Catlett Aug 03 2020

Review for Dr. Patel

My first televisit with Dr. Schultz was a great experience. Just as when he sees me in the office, he asked questions and was very thorough in walking me through my next steps. Dr. Schultz and his staff are consistently amazing and professional.

Kimberley Aug 02 2020

Review for Dr. Schultz

Dr. Zochowski is a wonderful plastic surgeon and is very skilled at what he does. He is friendly and really takes the time to explain what he will be doing and took the time to answer questions at length.

Columbus, OH Aug 01 2020

Review for Dr. Zochowski

Dr. Spiess successfully treated my Minears Disease when my family doctor couldn't diagnose my condition. Very happy with the practice and Dr. Spiess

Aug 01 2020

Review for Dr. Spiess

Nana to 2 boys Aug 01 2020

Review for Dr. Holinga

Matt Walker Jul 31 2020

Review for Dr. Zochowski

I love the personal care that I received from my doctor and the staff as well they are outstanding in patient care.

Geri D???? Jul 31 2020

Review for Dr. Briones

Location

Mount Carmel West

793 W State St, Columbus, OH 43222

Frequently Asked Questions

Where is Mount Carmel West located?

Has Mount Carmel West won any recent awards from Healthgrades?

Does Mount Carmel West score well in safety ratings?