Saint Catherine of Siena Medical Center

60%

Patients that would definitely recommend
10% lower than the national average

Safety Ratings

How well a hospital safeguards patients from potential complications

No events relating to foreign objects left in body during a surgery or procedure

3 ratings were worse than expected

10 ratings were as expected

  • Death in procedures where mortality is usually very low
  • Death following a serious complication after surgery
  • Collapsed lung due to a procedure or surgery in or around the chest
  • Catheter-related bloodstream infections acquired at the hospital
  • Hip fracture following surgery
  • Excessive bruising or bleeding as a consequence of a procedure or surgery
  • Acute kidney dysfunction following surgery
  • Respiratory failure following surgery
  • Breakdown of abdominal incision site
  • Accidental cut, puncture, perforation or hemorrhage during medical care
Learn more about patient safety ratings

Hospital Quality

Clinical Ratings

Research hospital performance and talk to your doctor about what's right for you

Data Source

Patient Experience

Patient experience measures tell you how patients felt about the care they received at the hospital. These measures are based on the Hospital Consumer Assessment of Healthcare Providers and Systems (HCAHPS) survey data from the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS).

Learn more about patient experience
58%

Patients who gave a rating of 9 or 10
11% lower than the national average

60%

Would definitely recommend
10% lower than the national average

Saint Catherine of Siena Medical Center

National Average

Communication with doctors

Percent of patients who said that doctors always listened to them and explained things well

100%50%0%74%81%

Communication with nurses

Percent of patients who said that nurses always listened to them and explained things well

100%50%0%77%78%

Communication about medicines

Percent of patients who said that staff always explained medicines before giving them to patients

100%50%0%57%63%

Discharge Information

Percent of patients who said they were given information about recovering at home

100%50%0%86%84%

Care Transition

Percent of patients who said they understood their care needs when they left the hospital

100%50%0%42%53%

Responsiveness of hospital staff

Percent of patients who said they always received help quickly from hospital staff

100%50%0%57%66%

Saint Catherine of Siena Medical Center

National Average

Quietness

Percent of patients who said the area around their rooms was always kept quiet at night

100%50%0%42%60%

Cleanliness

Percent of patients who said their room and bathroom were always kept clean

100%50%0%71%73%

Providers

Provider Reviews

Dr Jamal performed my prostatectomy at St Catherine’s Hospital, which I highly recommend. I had minimal pain post op and little side effects which have been getting better in time. It’s been four months and my psa is undetectable. If you’re opting for surgery, Dr Jamal is the best.

Nicholas S. Jul 07 2020

Review for Dr. Jamal

Very uplifting, good listener and explanations are very direct and easy to understand.

Jacqueline C. Jul 07 2020

Review for Dr. Thompson III

Prompt, professional courteous and explained my condition in understandable terms.

Gene Trombetta Jul 07 2020

Review for Dr. Baharestani

Dr. Mullins has operated on me twice and, both times, I couldn't have possibly been happier with his work. He is caring, attentive, and thorough. My recovery was smooth and follow up appointments went well. To anyone needing back surgery I highly recommend Dr. Mullins.

Jul 06 2020

Review for Dr. Mullins

The office staff and nursing staff were excellent at the Medford location. Dr. Patel is outstanding; professional, yet personable. Top notch care!!!

Deborah Jul 06 2020

Review for Dr. Patel

Dr. Baharestani was professional, caring and kind. Appointment was informative and resourceful. I would recommend Dr. Baharestani!

Jul 05 2020

Review for Dr. Baharestani

Dr Lubarsky and his staff were excellent. Dr Lubarsky provided thorough examination and suggestions for future. I was very pleased with the service and will definitely recommend Dr. Lubarsky as an excellent cardiologist.

Jadranka Skorin-Kapov Jul 04 2020

Review for Dr. Lubarsky

Spiro Jul 03 2020

Review for Dr. Lubarsky

Wow! Really thorough. Spent so much time with me in my first visit. Th is Doctor doesn’t miss a beat. He really knows his stuff.

Jul 03 2020

Review for Dr. Allen

Superb! Caring, patient, intelligent and down to earth. My favorite doc ever !

Jul 03 2020

Review for Dr. Allen

Great experience. Beautiful office. Great doctor. Super sweet staff. It’s a win all the way.

Jul 03 2020

Review for Dr. Allen

So happy I found dr allen. He is the best doctor ever. A great listener and sooo smart.

Jul 03 2020

Review for Dr. Allen

Jul 03 2020

Review for Dr. Hossain

thankful he saved my life and help find what was harming me

Doraine T. Jul 03 2020

Review for Dr. Thompson III

Caring compassionate doctor and staff

Brenda A. Jul 03 2020

Review for Dr. Thompson III

i had a great post op visit . thank you for doing so much

Christopher C. Jun 30 2020

Review for Dr. Thompson III

Sam Husney Jun 28 2020

Review for Dr. Fuentes-Felix

Dr. Jobanputra is an excellent doctor. He takes time to explain things to you and makes sure you understand what is wrong and what steps can and will be taken to heal you. I highly recommend him!

Robert Hofmann Jun 27 2020

Review for Dr. Jobanputra

the doc was awesome and he did a great job fixing me up i was in so much pain and now i feel like a new man

Giovanni G. Jun 25 2020

Review for Dr. Thompson III

just had gallbladder surgery and I came to the office worried about my incisions. Dr. Thompson took the time to explain it all to me and let me know everything is normal. Also took the time to discuss other health issues as well regarding losing weight

Vanessa W. Jun 24 2020

Review for Dr. Thompson III

He is the best

Sherry Morganelli Jun 23 2020

Review for Dr. Ryan

I met a doctor who is knowledgeable , knows what he is doing . I felt comfortable with a doctor who can listen and give good recommendations

Jun 23 2020

Review for Dr. Thomas

He was great and helped me in an emergency situation. Excellent bedside manner.

Francisca U. Jun 19 2020

Review for Dr. Thompson III

Dr. Thompson performed my surgery in the hospital and was amazing in doing so. He called my house to check up and see how things were, and was phenomenal in the follow up visit.

M. R. Jun 17 2020

Review for Dr. Thompson III

D. W. Jun 16 2020

Review for Dr. Thompson III

Jun 16 2020

Review for Dr. Gutman

Jun 16 2020

Review for Dr. Adler

He is very thorough and shows concern for patients. He is very patient when you ask him questions and always lets me know his opinion.

NV2NY Jun 16 2020

Review for Dr. Nawaz

Love all the doctors there. Extremely helpful and knowledgeable. Staff is also very friendly!

Racheal Jun 12 2020

Review for Dr. Oustecky

Always parking. Always on time. Dr. Obrien is always concerned with my health. She is kind and respectful. Dr. Obrien is also very up to date on current practices. I am a Registered Nurse and I think Dr. Obrien is the best doctor that I have ever had.

Lesle Northgard Jun 11 2020

Review for Dr. O'Brien

He's absolutely fantastic. From start to finish I could tell Dr. Mullins cared about my issue and was determined to fix it. My surgery was well executed and the recovery went smoothly. I feel great! Highly recommend.

Jun 11 2020

Review for Dr. Mullins

Kelly Marrero Jun 11 2020

Review for Dr. Ryder

Joe Pennino Jun 10 2020

Review for Dr. Kiridly

After running the gamut with many afib "specialists" - Mt. Sinai in Manhattan, etc- I was so lucky to meet Dr. Webber. All the positive things said by the others here are just simply true. Thanks Dr. Webber, still beating regular after more than a year.

john porter Jun 10 2020

Review for Dr. Weber

Excellent care

Lillian M. Jun 10 2020

Review for Dr. Thompson III

Ed Goldstein Jun 09 2020

Review for Dr. Lerner

Very thorough and personable

Dana Kelly Jun 04 2020

Review for Dr. Christoforou

Dr Light is caring , gentle , compassionate and a skilled talented surgeon . When ever I had an appointment it was as if I was talking to a friend . He made me feel comfortable and confident and put up with my husbands jokes . I highly recommend Dr Light he’s amazing .

Gina Jun 04 2020

Review for Dr. Light

Dr. Weber is not only super smart but has the rare quality of listening and showing genuine interest and compassion to his patients. I would recommend him highly to anyone.

Patricia Roberts Jun 04 2020

Review for Dr. Weber

She is an exceptional-surgeon who operated on me last year for colon cancer. Because of her skills I had almost no pain and I have recovered fully without any side effects. She truly saved my life.

Jun 03 2020

Review for Dr. Genua

Jun 02 2020

Review for Dr. Sollazzo

Rather Not Say my Name Jun 01 2020

Review for Dr. Escamilla

Virtual visit

Jun 01 2020

Review for Dr. Abbasi

May 30 2020

Review for Dr. Alpern

He is a disgrace to his profession

May 29 2020

Review for Dr. Schwartz

From the first visit to the surgery it was a great experience

Chris C May 29 2020

Review for Dr. Mileto

excellent experience I would Dr. MIleto again if the need arises

Joseph Guerra May 29 2020

Review for Dr. Mileto

in good hands

Brenda L. S. May 27 2020

Review for Dr. Thompson III

I had a great experience with Dr. Thompson. He was there with me every step of the way. Made sure every question was answered and everything surgically went as planned. Would recommend Dr. Thompson to anyone and everyone!

Steven M. May 27 2020

Review for Dr. Thompson III

Dr Thompson was very kind and professional. He expedited my surgery so I would not be in pain. I am very appreciative of his service.

Margaret M. May 27 2020

Review for Dr. Thompson III

office staff is incompetent and lazy. In all my 60 years they are the worst!

May 22 2020

Review for Dr. Cesa

MDR May 21 2020

Review for Dr. Light

I had a very good experience with Dr.Ribaudo and his staff. They were very professional and thorough. Everyone was pleasant from start to finish. They were very comforting and understanding with my anxiety about the pet scan machine. I got my results very fast and would recommend him.

AnnMarie May 21 2020

Review for Dr. Ribaudo

Jeremy May 20 2020

Review for Dr. Abbasi

May 16 2020

Review for Dr. Gor

Dr. Mileto is an excellent orthopedist.

May 16 2020

Review for Dr. Mileto

Worst Dr. ever. Rude and dismissive.

Kelly Deininger May 14 2020

Review for Dr. Press

Dr Montana is a knowledgeable, compassionate physician.

IC May 13 2020

Review for Dr. Montana

Jack Byrnes May 13 2020

Review for Dr. Zavarella

Dr. Mileto did a wonderful job replacing my hip. He was reassuring and professional.

May 11 2020

Review for Dr. Mileto

Anthony DiMasso May 08 2020

Review for Dr. Dacosta

ER visit, didn’t bother to listen or read my prior history and attempted to admit with a misdiagnosis.

KM May 08 2020

Review for Dr. Baravarian

There is not transparency with prices. I left feeling ripped off. Not trustworthy. Treated me terrible as a patient.

May 05 2020

Review for Dr. Peredo

Stephanie J May 01 2020

Review for Dr. Mileto

My daughter was mauled by a dog when she was 7. Dr. Warm was the plastic surgeon on call and literally put her face back together, He is a masterful plastic surgeon and a wonderful human being .

Elizabeth Schilling May 01 2020

Review for Dr. Warm

I went to Dr. Gamez for a 2nd opinion after my initial orthopedist suggested surgery for a fifth metatarsal fracture. So glad I did! Under the treatment of Dr. Gamez my foot fully recovered and I can say I feel 100% better at this point - all WITHOUT surgery!

T. J. Avolese May 01 2020

Review for Dr. Gamez

Great doctor and great staff! Always upbeat and eager to help. If you need a doctor or allergist this is the office you want. You will be a patient for life. I can’t say enough good things about everyone in this office.! Thank you so much for doing what you do! Keep up the great work !

Brian D. Apr 30 2020

Review for Dr. Sabinsky

Apr 30 2020

Review for Dr. Sterling

Jerome bongiovi Apr 30 2020

Review for Dr. Mileto

best experience ever had everything was excellent

Jorenda H. Apr 29 2020

Review for Dr. Thompson III

great

C. N. Apr 29 2020

Review for Dr. Thompson III

Dr Abbasi listens. That is the most important aspect of the care he renders. I am grateful for his approach to the tremendous disc pain in my lower back. His plan is working for me and it will for you.

SAL Apr 28 2020

Review for Dr. Abbasi

Excellent Cardiologist and Interventionalist. Great bedside manner, cares about his patients, very intelligent and thorough.

Apr 28 2020

Review for Dr. Hormozi

I had lower back surgery done by him and the outcome was extremely excellent.. He's the MAN and he did a great job!! WOULD DEFINITELY USE HIM AGAIN!!???? R.Girardeau

R.Girardeau Apr 27 2020

Review for Dr. Kern

Dr, Ribaudo has been our cardiologist for many years His empathy his skills as a doctor are stellar. He is everything you could wish for as a doctor..

Elaine Salvitti Apr 26 2020

Review for Dr. Ribaudo

Anthony Apr 25 2020

Review for Dr. Schoor

Excellent to take care of all my lower back issues

Apr 23 2020

Review for Dr. Shady

Apr 23 2020

Review for Dr. Dewal

Kind and understanding Doctor!!

Margaret Poplinger Apr 21 2020

Review for Dr. Moskowitz

Dave Apr 21 2020

Review for Dr. Noori

great would recommend

B. M. Apr 21 2020

Review for Dr. Serure

Excellent-Explains everything-Kind-funny-Sometimes you just get that good vibe about some Drs-That’s what I got with Dr Montana-

Jean Parisi Apr 20 2020

Review for Dr. Montana

Catherine Gorman Apr 18 2020

Review for Dr. Mullins

Ricki A. DeSantis Apr 17 2020

Review for Dr. Kern

Dr. Azaz has been my doctor for 25 years. He always takes the time to listen and he explains things in a practical way that one can understand. He instills confidence.

Rod H. Apr 16 2020

Review for Dr. Azaz

Dr. Caiati is always thorough. Attends to your medical needs in a professional and interested manner. He is very knowledgeable.

Apr 14 2020

Review for Dr. Caiati

Class act, went out of his way to stay late for me. These are crazy times to say the least, Dr. Light is a true professional. I would recommend him to any and all.

Joseph Mele Apr 14 2020

Review for Dr. Light

What a great doctor! She recently saw me through the coronavirus, always staying a step ahead. I am so grateful for her diligence, knowledge and concern! She is the Best!!!

Suzanne S Apr 13 2020

Review for Dr. Dacosta

I like his Bedside manner he is a great surgeon I would recommend him to family and friends

John Fudenski Apr 12 2020

Review for Dr. Jacob

He saves my wife’s life in 2012 with his innovative treatment plan!!

Doug J. Apr 11 2020

Review for Dr. Popp

Always one step a head.

Apr 10 2020

Review for Dr. Bruno

Compassionate care. Clear instructions. Kind man. You need an eye doctor? You simply cannot do better.

S. R. Apr 09 2020

Review for Dr. Baharestani

Having a doctor who listens and does not dismiss your questions is a comforting thing before having surgery. Thank you Dr. Thompson!

Jodi D. Apr 08 2020

Review for Dr. Thompson III

Dr Hormozi is a great doctor he put four stents in my heart.. He explained everything and came to see me after the surgery I was very satisfied with him..

Norman Lorber Apr 05 2020

Review for Dr. Hormozi

Dr. Barbara Stumacher is a very sincere and caring doctor. Her services went well beyond my expectations. She takes her time with me and really goes over every aspect no matter how busy she is. I highly recommend her services.

Karin H. Smithtown, NY Apr 04 2020

Review for Dr. Stumacher

Dr. Oustecky is definitely one of the best doctors I’ve ever had. He’s not only professional but also caring and kind. I don’t think I could have asked for a better Doctor. I’m not seeing Dr. Oustecky anymore as I recently relocated to a different state but I wish him the very best continuing on.

Apr 02 2020

Review for Dr. Oustecky

Location

Saint Catherine of Siena Medical Center

50 Route 25A, Smithtown, NY 11787