Orlin & Cohen Orthopedic Group

Orthopedic Surgery, Hip & Knee Orthopedics · 11 Providers

Today: 10:00am - 6:00pm

  • Mon10:00am - 6:00pm
  • Tue12:00pm - 8:00pm
  • Wed9:00am - 5:00pm
  • Thu9:00am - 5:00pm
  • Fri8:00am - 3:30pm
  • SatClosed
  • SunClosed

Make an Appointment

Providers

Insurance Check

Language services

  • French
  • Hebrew
  • Portuguese
  • Russian
  • Spanish

Medical Services

Location

Orlin & Cohen Orthopedic Group

1101 Stewart Ave Ste 100, Garden City, NY 11530

Provider Reviews

Overall rating for providers

4.2

Based on 230 Reviews

I found him to be arrogant and a terrible listener.

Nov 04 2019

Review for Dr. Krochak

Oct 08 2019

Review for Dr. Shah

Excellent doctor & nurses. Very informative and caring.

Sep 30 2019

Review for Dr. Krochak

My daughter’s favorite doctor! She tore her ACL playing soccer and Dr. Mait got her back on the field in six months. He even came to her first game. There needs to be more doctors like him.

Rockville Center - Aug 05 2019

Review for Dr. Mait

in Garden City - Jun 27 2019

Review for Dr. Mait

Dr. Krochak is amazing. He got rid of my knee pain and I am now able to run again! He took the time to listen to me and explain me knee problem in terms I can understand. I would highly recommend him to anyone with knee issues.

none - Jun 20 2019

Review for Dr. Krochak

May 16 2019

Review for Dr. Milchteim

Excellent Job! Dr. Shah repaired my right knee. Surgery and follow up were smooth and painless. Highly recommend him. He is a very relaxed easy speaking Dr. and will spend time with you. Thanks Dr. Shah

Apr 19 2019

Review for Dr. Shah

I had a great experience. She was very thorough and explained everything to me.

Apr 16 2019

Review for Dr. Daves

Excellent doc. It’s been 6 months since Dr. Mait fixed my ACL and I’m as good as new.

Apr 02 2019

Review for Dr. Mait

Very good. Very gentle giving knee shots and explained my condition very thoroughly and all my options.

Mar 19 2019

Review for Dr. Shah

Mar 18 2019

Review for Dr. Goldstein

I can’t say enough great things about Dr. Germano, his PA Scott and his staff. I had a hip replacement Nov 1st and was driving in 10 days. He’s very compassionate and thorough when explaining everything. I highly recommend Dr. Germano!

in Merrick NY - Feb 18 2019

Review for Dr. Germano

Dr Dave’s is a really good pain management doctor. I’ve had a couple of procedures done by her and they were successfully done. Office staff never returns calls! That’s the major problem with O&C. The portal is terrible, you can’t contact the doctor or leave a message.

NY - Feb 13 2019

Review for Dr. Daves

in Coral Springs , FL - Feb 06 2019

Review for Dr. Levitz

Dr. Shah took great care of my son with his knee injury from football. Very thorough, professional as well as personable. Great combination.

in NY - Jan 10 2019

Review for Dr. Shah

in Manorville, NY - Dec 19 2018

Review for Dr. Shah

Dr. Shah was extremely professional and helpful when my 8 year-old son broke his collarbone!

Rockville Centre, NY - Dec 18 2018

Review for Dr. Shah

in Garden City, NY - Dec 13 2018

Review for Dr. Shah

True Professional, Took the time to answer my questions, made a spot on diagnosis. Gave me options and saw it through to the end.

Nov 30 2018

Review for Dr. Shah

Had a wonderful experience with Dr. Mait. Very professional, caring and kind. He explained very thoroughly the procedure he was doing on me and I’m recovering nicely. I highly recommend him.

East Hills , NY - Nov 23 2018

Review for Dr. Mait

He replaced my hip and total knee replacement. Excellent care.

Medford, NY - Oct 23 2018

Review for Dr. Germano

Dr. Shah took great care of my child. He was compassionate and understanding while addressing the issue and making my child better quickly.

Brookville, NY - Oct 18 2018

Review for Dr. Shah

Oct 15 2018

Review for Dr. Germano

Oct 11 2018

Review for Dr. Levitz

DR SHAH WAS VERY THOROUGH IN EXPLAINING THE NATURE OF MY ILNESS - HE GAVE VERY IN DEPTH EXPLANATION ON THE CARE / WHAT MY LIMITATION WERE IN TERMS OF ACTIVITY AND TIME FRAME FOR HEALING .

in DIX HILLS, NY - Oct 01 2018

Review for Dr. Shah

He is very serious about his profession. Genuinely cares for his patients. Smart, right to the point, always welcoming with a smile. He operated on me. I had two knee replacements. I'm 42. He did an excellent job no infections barely a scar. Looking forward to seeing him for my last follow up.

in Farmingdale , NY - Sep 30 2018

Review for Dr. Germano

Exceptional professionalism and skill. All questions were addressed and well explained. All aspects of surgery and surgical recovery were explained in full

in NY, NY - Sep 12 2018

Review for Dr. Shah

Back pain that changed my life after my work injury significantly better after surgery with Dr T! Was initially reluctant to have surgery but after years of sufferers glad I did - Steve R

in Valley Stream, NY - Sep 02 2018

Review for Dr. Tarleton

in NY - Aug 31 2018

Review for Dr. Germano

in Oceanside, NY - Aug 17 2018

Review for Dr. Tarleton

Dr. Daves is the best. She listens and then follows through.

Aug 03 2018

Review for Dr. Daves

in Long Beach, NY - Aug 03 2018

Review for Dr. Shah

in Centereach - Jul 24 2018

Review for Dr. Shah

in Massapequa, NY - Jul 24 2018

Review for Dr. Shah

Dr. Shah is an excellent knee specialist. He has treated 3 people in my family. He is personable and caring. He is very thorough and treated my daughter as he would a professional athlete.

Jul 23 2018

Review for Dr. Shah

rude and condescending. I would not recommend him or this practice. They consistently overbook appointments so the wait is usually about an hour.

in merrick, NY - Jul 11 2018

Review for Dr. Shah

His manner was condescending and nasty. If I am paying for a service I expect to be treated respectfully. I will not go back, nor would I recommend any practice that he is associated with.

Jul 10 2018

Review for Dr. Shah

Dr. Mait has been a fantastic doc!! He has treated our whole family and we highly recommend him to friends all the time. Great bedside manner, great diagnostician, and has always clearly explained anything we could expect post-procedure. The best!

Jul 05 2018

Review for Dr. Mait

Dr. Mait saved my shoulder! He is also the kindest doctor I have ever been to.

in Roslyn - May 22 2018

Review for Dr. Mait

in New York - May 01 2018

Review for Dr. Daves

Feb 27 2018

Review for Dr. Levitz

in East Meadow, NY - Jan 23 2018

Review for Dr. Shah

in Massapequa - Nov 18 2017

Review for Dr. Shah

in Long Island, NY - Oct 07 2017

Review for Dr. Shah

in Bayport, NY - Oct 06 2017

Review for Dr. Shah

Dr. Shah did some work on me recently., He was thorough, answered all questions, and was very pleasant.. I definitely recommend him,

Malverne, NY - Oct 01 2017

Review for Dr. Shah

Definitely would recommend Dr. Shah. Happy with how he answered all my questions and explained everything clearly. Well organized office, very helpful staff.

in Oceanside, NY - Aug 29 2017

Review for Dr. Shah

Went to see dr Tarleton and was diagnosed with a lumbar cyst which he removed and I can now walk around without the pain going down my leg - highly recommended!

New York, NY - Aug 19 2017

Review for Dr. Tarleton

Dr. Shah may have experience as a knee doctor. However, his bedside manner is unpleasant and condescending. If you are a patient that needs TLC and wants someone who treats the WHOLE person, not just the knee, DO NOT go to him. I would not recommend him at all.

Plainview, NY - Jun 14 2017

Review for Dr. Shah

Waited in the waiting room for 45 minutes. Then, Dr. Levitz barely spoke with me. I visited him a few times and the combined time he spent talking with me was probably 3 minutes.

Commack, NY - May 16 2017

Review for Dr. Levitz

Caring and knowledgeable. Takes time to explain the problem and offers realistic solutions. I was treated after a serious car accident and saw Dr Milchteim quite often. I was treated like a family member.

in Merrick - Apr 27 2017

Review for Dr. Milchteim

Had multiple disk replaced as well as plate hardware for my cervical spine. Dr. Tarlton is an amazing surgeon and a true gentleman. I am currently going through recovery, hope to be up an running soon!! Thank you, Michael

Fredericksburg, VA - Mar 16 2017

Review for Dr. Tarleton

Excellent result - symptoms have totally resolved!

New York, NY - Feb 12 2017

Review for Dr. Tarleton

in Wantagh, NY - Feb 01 2017

Review for Dr. Levitz

Dr Shah is an excellent doctor who takes his time explaining options to his patients. His caring and expertise make me trust him and give me confidence in his recommended treatment. I will definitely recommend him to family and friends.

in Valley Stream, NY - Oct 28 2016

Review for Dr. Shah

Worst Doctor I have ever met.

in New York, NY - Oct 18 2016

Review for Dr. Milchteim

Woodbury, NY - Oct 06 2016

Review for Dr. Daves

Speaking from experience, Dr. Tarleton is the best at what he does - spine surgery. He is warm, honest, patient, and most of all, highly skilled at working with spinal issues. He is "the man" I would recommend to anybody in search of relief from all things spine related.

in Seaford NY - Sep 01 2016

Review for Dr. Tarleton

Merrick, NY - Aug 24 2016

Review for Dr. Milchteim

Dr. Shah has a God given talent. He is extremely patient and very knowledge in his field

in Holbrook, NY - Jun 26 2016

Review for Dr. Shah

great doctor and staff. Wait times can be excessive-I get around this by booking first or second appt. he is well worth it. Great disposition and really listens to you.

Wantagh, NY - Jun 23 2016

Review for Dr. Levitz

Very Profesional and knowledgeable. I feel comfortable for his answers to my questions. I feel very secure to have him taken care of me and my family as a Doctor.

in Inwood - Jun 21 2016

Review for Dr. Shah

in Merrick, NY - Jun 10 2016

Review for Dr. Levitz

in Baldwin, NY - Jun 09 2016

Review for Dr. Germano

in Syosset, NY - Jun 06 2016

Review for Dr. Daves

Mar 06 2016

Review for Dr. Tarleton

in Bethpage, NY - Feb 26 2016

Review for Dr. Milchteim