Elmwood Health Center

Internal Medicine, Obstetrics & Gynecology · 7 Providers

Average Rating of all Office Providers

Office Providers

Dr. Theodore Costich, MD

Dr. Theodore Costich, MD

Obstetrics & Gynecology

Dr. Sarah Finnegan, MD

Dr. Sarah Finnegan, MD

Clinical Neurophysiology


Office Provider Reviews


based on the average of 42 provider reviews for Elmwood Health Center

Review of Dr. Costich

- in Williamsville, NY |

My experience with Dr. Costich has always been wonderful. I have been with Dr. Costich for over 20 years and I cannot say enough amazing things about him! He is professional, compassionate, hard working, and knowledgeable. The entire staff has been with him for years- that also says a lot, and are all so helpful and understanding I cannot think of another Doctor, who I could give higher praise to.
Flag Comment
Was this review helpful?
Review of Dr. Costich

-Buffalo, NY |

Totally disregarded my birth plan and gave me a horrible episiotomy after screwing up my natural childbirth plan. Only go with this doc if you want unnecessary medical interventions and someone who disregards your wishes.
Flag Comment
Was this review helpful?
Review of Dr. Zambron

- in Buffalo, New York |

One of the finest doctors I have ever had and I'm in my seventies!
Flag Comment
Was this review helpful?
Review of Dr. Penn


Beware of this doctor!!. This doctor took advantage of my mom and has left her with scar tissue caused by laser treatments. It continues to be painful for her to walk. Please get a second opinion if you are in pain and Dr Penn just tells you it will take time to get rid of a planters wart!
Flag Comment
Was this review helpful?
Review of Dr. Costich

-Rochester, NY |

Dr. Costich is wonderful and I've recommended him to all my friends and family. I only wish I had started to see him sooner. He and his staff are welcoming and very thorough. He was amazing at calming my fears through my whole pregnancy
Flag Comment
Was this review helpful?
Review of Dr. Polisoto

- in Buffalo, NY |

Dr Polisoto was extremely helpful in taking the time to address my needs and options. He goes above and beyond to help you feel at ease.
Flag Comment
Was this review helpful?
Review of Dr. Costich

- in Attica, NY |

Dr. Costing is an amazing doctor. He was with me every step of the way with my son's birth. Now that I'm pregnant with our daughter, there isn't any other doctor I'd want delivering her.
Flag Comment
Was this review helpful?
Review of Dr. Costich

- in Getzville ny |

Very good doctor. I have been going to him for year's. He has delivered both my children and his staff are amazing. I recommend him highly.
Flag Comment
Was this review helpful?
Review of Dr. Blymire Jr

- in Buffalo NY |

For 2 years I requested Dr Blymire to do a hemoglobin A1C test as I felt I was diabetic. I have a family history as well as being of Hispanic and Native American ancestry. I exhibited all the classic symptoms of diabetes. He said the test was unnecessary as my fasting glucose level was normal. It took a diabetic crisis for him to do the test. The result, my hemoglobin A1C was over 12! I suffered for 2 years needlessly. He didn't even have the grace to apologize or admit his mistake.
Flag Comment
Was this review helpful?
Review of Dr. Costich

-Buffalo, NY |

Rude, Judgmental, callous.
Flag Comment
Was this review helpful?

Learn About Elmwood Health Center

60 Procedures

  • Abscess Or Cyst Drainage Or Aspiration
  • Abscess Or Fluid Incision And Drainage
  • Advance Directive End Of Life Planning
  • Anemia And Iron Deficiency Screening
  • Arterial Blood Gas Test (Abg)
  • C-Section
  • Cardiovascular Stress Test
  • Care Coordination For Complex Conditions And Procedures
  • Cholesterol Screening
  • Colpopexy
  • Colporrhaphy
  • Colposcopy
  • Destruction Or Excision Of Lesion Of Cervix (Incl. Leep)
  • Diabetes Counseling
  • Diabetes Screening
  • Dilation And Curettage
  • Eeg (Electroencephalogram)
  • Electrocardiogram (Ekg)
  • Excision, Shaving, Or Destruction Of Skin And Subcutaneous Tissue (Incl. Mohs Micrographic Surgery), Tissue Transfer
  • Fecal Occult Blood Test For Colorectal Cancer
  • Fetal Cardiac Monitoring
  • Fluid Contrast Ultrasound
  • Foot And Ankle Dislocationtreatment, Open
  • Foot And Ankle Fracture And Dislocation Treatment
  • Fracture Care
  • Gonorrhea Screening
  • Hearing Screening
  • Hepatitis C Virus Screening
  • Hepatitis Screening
  • Hysterectomy - Laparoscopic
  • Hysterectomy - Open
  • Hysteroscopy
  • Immunization
  • Incision And Removal Of Foreign Object
  • Incontinence Sling Procedure
  • Laparoscopic Surgical Procedure
  • Liver Function Test
  • Nail Avulsion And Excision
  • Newborn Metabolic Screening
  • Osteoporosis Screening
  • Pap Smear
  • Paracentesis
  • Pregnancy Test
  • Pregnancy Ultrasound
  • Prostate Cancer Screening
  • Pulmonary Function Test
  • Rapid Flu Test
  • Removal Of Reproductive Organs (Hysterectomy, Oophorectomy, Salpingectomy, Salpingo-Oophorectomy, Resection Of Peritoneal Malignancy)
  • Rh Incompatibility Screening
  • Sexually Transmitted Infections Screening
  • Smoking Cessation Counseling
  • Thyroid Screening
  • Trichomoniasis Screening
  • Tubal Ligation
  • Vaginal Birth After Cesarean (Vbac)
  • Vaginal Delivery And Vbac
  • Vaginal Surgery
  • Vulvectomy
  • Wellness Examination
  • Wound Repair


Read More

Who We Are

  • Pediatric and Adult Developmental Disabilities Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation Management

Language Services

  • Spanish

Elmwood Health Center accepts 15 insurance carriers

  • Aetna
  • Blue Cross Blue Shield
  • Capital District Physician's Health Plan (CDPHP)
  • Cigna
  • EmblemHealth
  • Empire Blue Cross Blue Shield
  • Fidelis Care
  • First Health (Coventry Health Care)
  • Independent Health
  • MVP Health Care
  • Medicaid
  • MultiPlan
  • UnitedHealthCare
  • Univera Healthcare
  • Universal Health Network
*Please verify this information when scheduling an appointment.