Sanford Health

Orthopedic Surgery, Physician Assistant (PA) · 9 Providers

Average Rating of all Office Providers

Office Providers

Tana Ciaverella, PA

Tana Ciaverella, PA

Physician Assistant (PA)

Dr. Ian Fyfe, MD

Dr. Ian Fyfe, MD

Orthopedic Surgery

Allen Gibson, PA-C

Allen Gibson, PA-C

Physician Assistant (PA)

Office Provider Reviews


based on the average of 41 provider reviews for Sanford Health

Review of Dr. Fyfe


He did a bilateral arthroscopy in 2017, and my knees came out great. So I recently called about having a knee replacement, and someone in his office said he doesn't do knee surgery anymore?
Flag Comment
Was this review helpful?
Review of Dr. Fyfe


I would not see him for anything but knees. Not a good diagnostician and his nurse Lisa is terrible, as has been mentioned. Does not care about patients. Total waste of time and money. Go to sports medicine instead and you might get a diagnosis and some help.
Flag Comment
Was this review helpful?
Review of Dr. Icenogle Sr

- in Dickinson, ND |

Dr. Icenogle Sr has every exceptional orthopedic surgeon quality a patient could want. He is very educated, personable, has courage to make difficult decisions. He has good communication skills with everyone that is involved in each patients case. He is very careful when prescribing medications for pain etc. He will not prescribe any pain meds unless you absolutely need it & if so, only in a small quantity & abide by the drug rules. He also is available at anytime. He is the best Dr. Thanks
Flag Comment
Was this review helpful?
Review of Dr. Icenogle Sr

- in Mandan, ND |

Dr Icenogle and his staff are awesome! Dr Icenogle performed my first wrist surgery back in Feb of 2018 and it went so well that I just had him do my other wrist this past Sept 2018. He is so easy to talk to and explains everything ahead of time so thoroughly. I never feel rushed and feel like he is truly listening. If I ever need anything done in the future, I will definitely return to Dr Icenogle and his staff! I will also definitely recommend him! A Special Shout Out to Al, Olivia and Julie!
Flag Comment
Was this review helpful?
Review of Dr. O'Regan

- in Rugby, ND |

Dr. O'Regan did a knee replacement surgery on my right knee and the entire experience from the first appointment to post-op appointments has been fantastic. He and his staff took time to explain the procedure and answered all of my questions as we moved through the process. I will definitely have Dr. O'Regan and the Sanford team do my left knee when the time comes.
Flag Comment
Was this review helpful?
Review of Dr. Icenogle Sr

-Bismarck , ND |

He rushes through things to quickly and doesn’t explain things he leaves you hanging. After my surgery is done then he decides to share with me that the surgery may not help. WTH! I wouldn’t of had the surgery if I knew that before hand.
Flag Comment
Was this review helpful?
Review of Dr. Carpenter

- in Mandan, ND |

Dr. Carpenter and staff are excellent. I had a total knee replacement a month ago, and couldn't be happier with the results and care provided by Dr. Carpenter and his staff.
Flag Comment
Was this review helpful?
Review of Dr. Icenogle Sr


Bedside manner leaves little to be desired. Very arrogant man who can be dismissive of your concerns or symptoms.
Flag Comment
Was this review helpful?
Review of Dr. Fyfe


I was "bone on bone" and in a lot of pain. Dr. Fyfe recommended a TKR (total knee replacement). It went very badly. My range of motion after 2 months was less than 80 degrees, and he did a MUA (manipulation under anesthesia). It was horrible, very painful afterwards and did not improve my knee function. I had to have revision surgery from another orthopedist. I spent 2 years going through all this, and I still can't do the things I could do before Dr. Fyfe did the surgery.
Flag Comment
Was this review helpful?
Review of Dr. Fyfe

- in Bismarck , ND |

Dr Fyfe is an amazing doctor and surgeon. Unfortunately I will not continue to see him due to his nurse Lisa. She is very rude and lacks any empathy.
Flag Comment
Was this review helpful?

Learn About Sanford Health

68 Procedures

  • Acl Surgery
  • All Shoulder Or Elbow Replacement Procedures
  • Arm Surgery
  • Arthroscopic Shoulder Surgery
  • Carpal Tunnel Release
  • De Quervain'S Release
  • Dressing And-Or Debridement Of Wound, Infection, Or Burn (Incl. Negative Pressure Wound Therapy)
  • Dupuytren'S Contracture Injection
  • Elbow Arthroscopy
  • Elbow Fracture And Dislocation Treatment
  • Elbow Fracture And-Or Dislocation Treatment, Closed
  • Elbow Fracture And-Or Dislocation Treatment, Open
  • Elbow Replacement
  • Elbow Tenotomy
  • Epidural Block, Facet Blocks
  • Excision Of Femur Or Knee
  • Excision Of Radius Or Ulna
  • Excision Of Scapula, Clavicle, Rib, Or Sternum
  • Excision Of Tibia Or Fibula
  • Foot And Ankle Dislocationtreatment, Open
  • Foot And Ankle Fracture And Dislocation Treatment
  • Foot And Ankle Fracture Treatment, Closed
  • Foot And Ankle Fracture Treatment, Open
  • Foot And Ankle Ligament And Tendon Repair
  • Fracture Care
  • Hand And Wrist Fracture And Dislocation Treatment
  • Hand And Wrist Fracture Treatment, Closed
  • Hand And Wrist Fracture Treatment, Open
  • Hand Or Wrist Tendon Transfer
  • Herniated Disc Surgery
  • Hip Fracture And Dislocation Treatment
  • Hip Fracture And-Or Dislocation Treatment, Closed
  • Hip Fracture And-Or Dislocation Treatment, Open
  • Hip Replacement
  • Hip Replacement Revision
  • Hip Resurfacing
  • Joint Drainage
  • Knee And Leg Fracture And Dislocation Treatment
  • Knee And Lower Leg Fracture Treatment, Closed
  • Knee And Lower Leg Fracture Treatment, Open
  • Knee Arthroscopy
  • Knee Replacement
  • Knee Replacement Revision
  • Knee Surgery
  • Lamina Procedures (Incl. Laminectomy, Laminoplasty, Laminotomy)
  • Myofascial Trigger Point Injection
  • Nerve Block, Somatic
  • Neuroplasty
  • Peripheral Nerve Block
  • Platelet-Rich Plasma Injection (Prp)
  • Resection Or Ablation Of Bone Tumor, Partial Or Complete Resection Of Bone, Debridement Of Bone
  • Reverse Total Shoulder And Total Shoulder Replacement
  • Revision Of Shoulder Or Elbow Replacement
  • Rotator Cuff Surgery
  • Separated Femoral Epiphysis Treatment
  • Shoulder Dislocation Treatment
  • Shoulder Fracture And Dislocation Treatment
  • Shoulder Fracture Treatment
  • Spinal Fusion
  • Spinal Nerve Block
  • Spinal Reconstructive Surgery For Deformities
  • Steroid Injection
  • Synovial Biopsy
  • Trigger Finger Release
  • Trigger Point Injection
  • Viscosupplementation With Hyaluronate
  • Wrist Fusion
  • Wrist Replacement


Read More

Who We Are

  • Orthopedic Hand Surgery

Language Services

  • Spanish

Sanford Health accepts 16 insurance carriers

  • Aetna
  • American Republic
  • Assurant Health
  • Blue Cross Blue Shield
  • Cigna
  • Commercial Insurance Company
  • First Health (Coventry Health Care)
  • Humana
  • Mail Handlers Benefit Plan (MHBP)
  • Medica
  • Medicaid
  • MultiPlan
  • Thrivent Financial
  • Tricare
  • UnitedHealthCare
  • Wells Fargo Insurance


Read More
*Please verify this information when scheduling an appointment.